Tonight’s episode of American Idol may look more like a genre-bending concert festival, but we’re promised there will be results at some point, too.
Does anyone remember the olden days, when Idol results shows were a half hour? It was just “Here we are. There you go. See you next week.” These are the days I long for. Unfortunately, when you’re the #1 show in America – well maybe not anymore – then everyone wants to hock themselves on your show. Hence, hour-long results show from now until the end of time.
Rascal Flatts is up first. It’s funny that Lady Antebellum is performing later, because – and let’s face it – they’ve stolen Rascal Flatts’ career. That’s right, I said it. Sure, the Flatts boys are still popular and still sell tons of records and concert tickets, but Lady Antebellum definitely stole some, or most, of their thunder. The performance is pretty good, though. Not amazing, but pretty good.
Since we all love the Ford music videos, tonight we get a look at some behind the scenes action at the shoot. Because Idol is always original and inventive, tonight’s video is all about Vampires. Crystal and Siobhan definitely make the best vampires. Siobhan-bies everywhere are overjoyed.
After the behind the scenes business, we get a look at the actual Ford video. Shockingly, I don’t hate it. It’s certainly one of the least annoying ones of the season. That’s enough for me at this point.
Now the gang is attending a screening of Shrek Forever After. And lookie, Ryan has a cameo in the film. Synergy at work, people. The degree to which Ryan’s narcissism has progressed during the course of nine seasons has been fascinating. Someone should really study this guy.
After the video clip, Cameron Diaz and Antonio Banderas chat with Ryan onstage. Ryan makes a horrid joke about Fiona looking hotter in person, completely negating the entire moral theme of the Shrek movies, which I’ve always thought was to let your inner beauty shine. Clearly, Ryan has no inner beauty to speak of.
Time for some real results. Ryan is splitting the group into sets of two. Perhaps it will only be a bottom two, after all? Siobhan to the end of the stage. Aaron to the middle. Michael to the near side. Lee joins Siobhan, Crystal to Aaron and Casey with Michael. That looks right to me, assuming Michael and Casey are the bottom two. Hmmm…what’s this? Ryan pulls Siobhan and walks her over to Casey and Michael. Rude! That’s the bottom three – with Siobhan-bhan! Screw you, Ryan.
Another performance – this one taped, however, reminding me that Idol is still bad at pretending everything is happening on one night.
Anywho, Sons of Sylvia feels like a new breed of glam country that Carrie Underwood has started. I hadn’t heard much of them before this performance, but they kind of won me over. I didn’t love the ‘We love you’ comment at the end, because they aren’t famous enough to be telling millions of people they love them, but I digress. I still really enjoyed their performance. What a great opportunity for them, too, to perform for this kind of an audience. I foresee a large iTunes bump in their future.
Ryan welcomes us back by weirdly flirting with a girl in the audience, telling her she looks like a Kardashian. This guy needs to hang his hat and call it a day. It’s painful to watch.
Finally, Lady Antebellum performs, and it’s predictably amazing. “Need You Now” is such an amazing song, and I love the way they sing to each other at the end. I’m sure they aren’t an item, but in my head they are. An item that sometimes has problems, causing them to write really painful, beautiful songs. Here’s to continued strife that benefits the rest of us with good music! I wish Lady Antebellum could win this season, but alas, they cannot. This performance was also taped, FYI.
Rascal Flatts is back to perform with Shakira. (This one is happening live, believe it or not.) Shakira is such a pleasing performer to watch. Her songs are catchy enough, her hips are so honest it hurts and she smiles a lot. It’s infectious. I actually quite like this duet. It’s sort of Latin/Pop/Country…in a good way.
Back to the results. Michael is safe, which means either Siobhan-bhan or Casey are leaving. I’m getting the feeling it’s the end of the line for Siobhan-bhan, which bums me out and irritates me beyond belief. Even though I don’t like Casey much, he shouldn’t be in the bottom two, either. He was good last night.
The extra space is a moment of silence dedicated to the Idol memory of everyone’s favorite glassblower, Siobhan-bhan Magnus. That’s right. She’s voted off. I’m 95% pissed off and 5% laughing right now. Laughing because it makes perfect sense. This season has been disappointment after disappointment. Why would I think the disappointments were to end? I’m fairly positive this is the worst top five ever in the history of singing competitions.
Siobhan is singing “Think” and killing it, as expected. She’s hugging her family, and I’m completely riveted. I’m also shaking a bit. The bizarre mixture of grief and anger is not good for a boy like me. I don’t even feel sad, really, just irritated.
Despite the overwhelming feeling of disgust that is filling my body, I feel like I got some Idol closure for the first time ever, due to the lengthy farewell we got with Siobhan. All the judges hugged her, praised her and she got to go out with a killer performance and a fittingly peculiar and charming video package. I’ll never forget you, Siobhan-bhan. To the rest of the top five, I’ve already forgotten most of you.

Siobhan-bhan's Farewell