Tons of drama – and even more media attention – surrounding tonight’s episode. Will she perform? Won’t she? Will she be disqualified? We must know!
About five minutes before show time, we find out that Crystal Bowersox will, indeed, be performing. Gasp! And there she is!
Time to meet the judges, whom we’ve already met…countless times. Ok, what is this nonsense with Kara and Simon? “Do you want me?” Bleh. Kara is doing her best Paula impersonation, this season, and it’s a lackluster homage.
Crystal Bowersox, “As Long as I Can See Light”: We might as well start with her, right? Everything surrounding her ‘illness’ has been so hush hush that it’s made things quite exciting a lot earlier than usual. If things proceed at this rate, I’ll certainly be on some sort of assisted breathing regimen by the time we’re down to the final four or five. This performance is all kinds of amazing. She just exudes confidence, and she clearly belongs on stage. The judges are tripping all over themselves, telling her how good she was. Simon even pulls out the Kelly Clarkson comparison! Double gasp!! It’s deserved, though. To think, she was (and probably still is) so sick. After last week’s performance, which was just aight, it’s nice to see Crystal deliver the goods. Lilith Fair 2010, watch out!
Haeley Vaughn, “The Climb”: Omg, headbands! So many headbands! And smiles for days. I can’t imagine Simon is enjoying her video package, chock full of happy happy, joy joy. I am one of the few people that actually liked Haeley’s take on The Beatles last week, but even I’m not really feeling this song as much. She’s pitchy in many parts, but there are some bright moments, too. There’s no way the judges will like this. I’m nervous for her. Aaaaand…they hated it. Simon delivers the final blow by telling her that he doesn’t want to make it worse, and then proceeding to make fun of her. It’s not looking good for Haeley. At least she’s still smiling.
Lacey Brown, “Kiss Me”: Lacey seemed to be sitting pretty heading into Top 24 week. That mysterious clip of her singing “Wonderful World” left everyone wanting more. And then she butchered “Landslide” and we all went, “Whaaa???” This week, she takes Kara’s advice (a scary notion) and goes with Sixpence None the Richer. Would you believe me if I told you that my first (real-ish) kiss took place while this song was playing in the background? It did. And would you believe that I actually missed the poor girl’s mouth, and kissed mostly her nostrils? That also happened. It didn’t work out. And I’m not sure it’s going to work out for Lacey and American Idol, because, although this song was a definite improvement from last week, the judges are still less than impressed. Better, yes, but maybe a little too late.
Katie Stevens, “ Put Your Records On”: Katie’s package reveals a charmingly dorky personality that is not unlike last year’s situation with Allion Iraheta. If anything, Katie is less awkward. This performance is her attempt at showing the judges that she can act her age. Unfortunately for her, they still aren’t happy. Randy at least liked the end of the song. The others gave her the same old story about singing songs that a 17 year old should be singing. I thought the performance was pretty good, myself. My biggest gripe isn’t so much the age she portrays in her performances, it’s the fact that she’s not really showing off her voice. She has that ‘big ol’ voice,’ right Randy? She should be belting like no other at this point in the competition. Get it together, girl.
Didi Benami, “Lean on Me”: Let’s get right to the point on this one. I thought this was way better than the judges gave her credit for. It was not the perfect performance, by any means, but it was also not the heaping pile of poo that the judges made it out to be during their slaughtering of poor, frail Didi. Last week it seemed like Didi had gotten her crying issues under control, but tonight they came flooding back, literally. Well, almost. She did her best to restrain her tears on stage. I have a feeling, though, that as I type this they are following Didi around backstage with “Caution: Wet Floor” signs. Poor Didi. I hope the sympathy votes kick in.
Michele Delamor, “With Arms Wide Open”: Well, at the very least Michele wins the award for the most surprising song choice. For me, for you, for her, though, this was not all of that. I thought the last third of it was a helluva hot mess, with not many notes in pitch. Apparently I was wrong (I strongly disagree), because Simon and Kara thought she was nearly amazing. I think she has a good voice, but I did not think the performance was anywhere near what they were trying to sell it to us as. What I did like was the flash to Michele’s Mini Me’s in the audience. That moment was both creepy and endearing. A very rare combination.
Lily Scott, “A Change is Gonna Come” : Did anyone catch the way she stared into the camera just a little while longer, as Ryan cut to her video package? I thought that was amazing and hilarious. Lily is definitely one of the major players this year, and this is another good performance. I’m more on Simon’s side of the split panel, though, because I liked it, but I didn’t think it was the “moment” that Kara said it was. I think Kara’s just yearning for a moment so badly that she’s creating ones in her head. I also agree with Simon about Crystal being better than Lily tonight. That being said, Lily should be here for quite some time. She’s a real contender in this year of the Un-Idol.
Katelyn Epperly, “The Scientist”: I’ve definitely given this girl a hard time. Maaaaaybe I was a tad premature in my initial assessment, but I stand by all I’ve said, because she presented herself as kind of trashy in the early goings. Since then, I’ve started to really warm up to her. I loved this performance, and I thought her playing the piano (that beautiful white piano!), made for a brilliant moment. Randy and Ellen gave her a hard time about it being too slow, which is such a copout. Randy is always wishy washy and it’s hard to know what he’ll think, but what happened to the nice, dancin’ in the aisles Ellen? At least Kara and Simon gave her some kudos. She deserved a lot more credit than she got, though. I even thought this performance, with the piano and the lighting, was more of a “moment” than Lily’s.
Paige Miles, “Walk Away”: Well, I’m instantly drawn to people with amazing taste in music, so Paige gets major points for singing a Shelly song…and for singing it mostly in its original style. I like nearly all of Paige’s performance. Some parts were better than others, but overall I thought she did a nice job with the song. And seeing someone bop around the stage, singing an upbeat song, was a refreshing change of pace. Aside from Ellen, the judges were kind of ‘eh’ about Paige’s performance. They all love her voice, though. I think that – coupled with singing so late in the show – will probably help her stick around.
Siobhan Magnus, “Think”: I. Love. This. Girl. And I would love to see her with that rockin’ Mohawk. I was really concerned that Idol producers would shy away from featuring Siobhan any more than necessary due to her slightly peculiar demeanor. A demeanor that fills me with happiness and smiles. Her vocals were on point, yet again, and her awkward step touch dancing and flimsy finger pointing completes the perfectly imperfect package that is Siobhan. The bulk of her performance was simply a prelude, however, to the most glorious glory note there ever was. The most amazing thing about it was the way it just sort of happened. She was singing, she was singing, and then she opened her mouth and hit that totally bananas note. I didn’t think Siobhan could make me any happier until she gave thanks to the Clarkson for helping her to discover how to belt. We all thank you, Kelly. All of the judges praised the performance, too, and specifically praised the note. If all goes as planned, Siobhan will be belting and step touching for many, many more weeks.
So that’s that. Two ladies are leaving us tomorrow night, and I’m betting it’ll be Haeley and Didi, though I think Lacey is in the running, too. I’ve been a fan of all three of these gals, but the judges’ comments tonight made it seem as though the writing is already on the wall. Siobhan is still my favorite, but Crystal and Lily are proving to be consistently strong. Katie needs to get herself together, ala Andrew Garcia, but I think she still has a shot. And I’m even warming up to Katelyn. The GaGa piano really helped.
